Percolator Vs Drip Coffee Maker: What’s The Difference?

There are many different methods to choose from. Among the most popular are the Percolator Vs Drip Coffee Maker. While some may argue that both methods achieve the same result, there are key differences that set these two appliances apart. The percolator, with its nostalgic design and distinct flavor, has been a staple in coffee making for many years.

On the other hand, the modern drip coffee maker offers convenience and consistency that may appeal to many coffee drinkers. Ultimately, the choice between a percolator and a drip coffee maker comes down to personal preference and desired qualities in a cup of coffee.

What is Percolator?


A percolator is a type of coffee pot that uses gravity to force water through ground coffee beans. It consists of three main parts – a bottom chamber for water, a central chamber for ground coffee, and a top chamber for the brewed coffee.

To use a percolator, you simply fill the bottom chamber with water and place ground coffee in the central chamber. As the water boils, it gets pushed up through a tube into the central chamber and then drips back down through holes in the lid, allowing it to mix with the ground coffee. This process is repeated until desired strength is achieved.

What is Drip Coffee Maker?


A drip coffee maker, also known as a filter coffee maker, is a popular household appliance that brews coffee by passing hot water through ground coffee beans and then filtering the brewed coffee into a carafe or mug.

To use a drip coffee maker, you simply pour water into its reservoir and place ground coffee in a filter basket. As the machine heats up, it drips hot water over the ground coffee, allowing it to slowly seep through and extract the flavor. The brewed coffee then drips into a carafe or mug below.

History of the Percolator

Percolators were the go-to method for brewing coffee in the early 20th century, with their popularity peaking during World War II when automatic drip coffee makers were not yet widely available. However, as technology advanced, drip coffee makers eventually overtook percolators in terms of popularity due to their ease of use.

History of the Drip Coffee Maker

The first drip coffee maker was invented in 1908 by German housewife Melitta Bentz, who wanted to create a cleaner and more efficient way of brewing coffee. Her invention consisted of a filtration system using paper filters, which is still commonly used in drip coffee makers today.

Percolator vs Drip Coffee Maker: Differences

Percolator vs Drip Coffee – Convenience


Percolators are a classic brewing method that has been around for centuries. They are relatively simple to use, but they can require more attention and manual intervention than drip coffee makers.

Steps to brew coffee with a percolator:

  1. Fill the percolator’s reservoir with water.
  2. Add coffee grounds to the basket.
  3. Place the basket in the percolator and close the lid.
  4. Place the percolator on the stovetop and turn on the heat.
  5. Wait for the coffee to brew. This can take anywhere from 5 to 10 minutes.
  6. Once the coffee is brewed, turn off the heat and remove the percolator from the stovetop.
  7. Pour the coffee into mugs and enjoy.

Advantages of percolators:

  • Relatively simple to use.
  • Produces a strong, bold cup of coffee.
  • Durable and can last for many years.

Disadvantages of percolators:

  • Can be difficult to control the brewing process.
  • Can over-brew coffee, making it bitter.
  • Requires more attention and manual intervention than drip coffee makers.

Drip Coffee Maker

Drip coffee makers are a more modern brewing method that is popular for their convenience and ease of use. They are a good choice for people who want a quick and easy cup of coffee without having to fuss with a percolator.

Steps to brew coffee with a drip coffee maker:

  1. Fill the coffee maker’s reservoir with water.
  2. Add a filter to the coffee maker’s basket.
  3. Add coffee grounds to the filter.
  4. Place the basket in the coffee maker and close the lid.
  5. Turn on the coffee maker.
  6. The coffee maker will automatically brew the coffee and dispense it into the carafe.
  7. Pour the coffee into mugs and enjoy.

Advantages of drip coffee makers:

  • Convenient and easy to use.
  • Produces a consistent cup of coffee.
  • Does not require as much attention and manual intervention as a percolator.

Disadvantages of drip coffee makers:

  • Can be more expensive than percolators.
  • May not produce as strong a cup of coffee as a percolator.

Percolator vs Drip Coffee – Taste

Percolator and drip coffee are two popular brewing methods that produce distinctly different cups of coffee. Here’s a breakdown of their taste profiles:

Percolator Coffee:

  • Bold and Robust Flavor: Percolators are known for brewing strong, full-bodied coffee with a rich, intense flavor. This is due to the continuous recirculation of hot water over the coffee grounds, which extracts more compounds from the beans.
  • Potential for Bitterness: Over-extraction, a common issue with percolators, can lead to a bitter taste. This occurs when the coffee grounds are exposed to hot water for too long, extracting undesirable compounds that contribute to bitterness.
  • Higher Caffeine Content: Percolators typically produce coffee with a higher caffeine content compared to drip coffee. This is because the continuous brewing process extracts more caffeine from the grounds.

Drip Coffee:

  • Clean and Smooth Flavor: Drip coffee is known for producing a clean, smooth, and balanced cup with subtle flavor nuances. This is due to the slow, controlled extraction process, which allows for a more delicate and nuanced brew.
  • Lighter Body: Drip coffee generally has a lighter body compared to percolator coffee. This is because the water passes through the grounds only once, extracting fewer compounds and resulting in a less intense brew.
  • Lower Caffeine Content: Drip coffee typically has a lower caffeine content compared to percolator coffee. This is because the single-pass extraction process extracts less caffeine from the grounds.

Choosing Your Preferred Brew:

  • Bold Coffee Lovers: If you enjoy a strong, rich cup of coffee with a robust flavor, a percolator might be your ideal choice.
  • Nuanced Coffee Enthusiasts: If you prefer a balanced, clean, and nuanced cup with subtle flavor profiles, a drip coffee maker might be a better fit.

Percolator vs Drip Coffee – Maintenance

Sure, here is a comparison of percolator and drip coffee makers in terms of maintenance:



Percolators are known for producing a strong, bold cup of coffee. However, they also require more maintenance than drip coffee makers. After each use, you should:

  • Remove the coffee grounds and rinse the basket.
  • Wash the lid, carafe, and any other removable parts in warm, soapy water.
  • Descale the percolator every few months to remove mineral buildup.

Drip Coffee Maker


Drip coffee makers are more user-friendly than percolators and produce a smoother, more balanced cup of coffee. They also require less maintenance. After each use, you should:

  • Rinse the carafe and filter.
  • Wash the coffeemaker basket in warm, soapy water.
  • Descale the coffeemaker every few months to remove mineral buildup.

Overall, drip coffee makers are easier to maintain than percolators. However, if you’re willing to put in a little extra effort, a percolator can produce a great cup of coffee.

Here is a table summarizing the maintenance requirements for percolators and drip coffee makers:

FeaturePercolatorDrip Coffee Maker
Daily cleaningRemove coffee grounds and rinse basketRinse carafe and filter
Weekly cleaningWash lid, carafe, and any other removable partsWash coffeemaker basket
Monthly cleaningDescaleDescale

In addition to the regular maintenance tasks listed above, you should also:

  • Store your coffeemaker in a cool, dry place.
  • Use filtered water to prevent mineral buildup.
  • Never leave coffee grounds in the coffeemaker for more than 24 hours.

By following these tips, you can help to extend the life of your coffeemaker and ensure that it continues to produce delicious coffee.

Percolator vs Drip Coffee – Price

Percolators and drip coffee makers are two of the most common methods of brewing coffee at home. Both methods are relatively inexpensive, and the cost of each type of coffee maker can vary depending on the brand, size, and features.


Percolators are typically more expensive than drip coffee makers, with prices ranging from $40 to $200. However, there are also some basic percolators that can be found for as little as $20. The price of a percolator will depend on its size, features, and brand. For example, a larger percolator with more features, such as a built-in timer or keep-warm function, will typically be more expensive than a smaller, basic percolator.

Drip Coffee Makers

Drip coffee makers can be found for a wide range of prices, from $15 to $200. The price of a drip coffee maker will depend on its size, features, and brand. For example, a larger drip coffee maker with more features, such as a built-in grinder or thermal carafe, will typically be more expensive than a smaller, basic drip coffee maker.

Which One Should You Choose?

Ultimately, the decision between a percolator and drip coffee maker comes down to personal preference. If you prefer a stronger, bolder cup of coffee and don’t mind being more involved in the brewing process, then a percolator may be the better option for you.

On the other hand, if you value convenience and prefer a milder taste in your coffee, then a drip coffee maker may be the way to go. Whichever you choose, both methods have their own unique history and charm that have withstood the test of time in the world of coffee brewing.

Related article:
Americano vs Coffee: Which One Should You Choose?


In conclusion, selecting either a percolator or a drip coffee maker depends on a variety of factors. Consider how much coffee you typically drink each day, the type of grind you are looking for as well as cost and convenience. Percolators are ideal if you prefer the bold, robustness taste that comes from freshly ground beans while drip coffee makers are great if you crave convenience and faster brewing times.


I’m Kara Chavez, and I love coffee. I like to create some of the best coffees around – espressos, lattes, macchiatos – you name it. I strive for perfection in my coffee-making skills, and I take great pride in providing a delicious cup of joe to my customers.

I’ve been working in the coffee industry for years now, and I know everything there is to know about making a perfect cup of coffee. My passion for coffee shines through in every cup that I make, and I hope that you’ll stop by soon so that I can share my love of coffee with you!

Leave a Comment